When It Happens Panel Get involved: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting 'OXFORD NEWS' to 80360 or email
4:10pm Tuesday 16th March 2010 in
A SOLDIER on leave from Afghanistan was not allowed to buy a bottle of whisky as his step-daughter was with him.
Sergeant Keith Cotton, who was on rest days before returning to the Royal Logistic Corps, based in Northern Ireland, was shocked when a cashier at Carterton’s Co-operative supermarket refused to sell him the spirit while shopping with 15-year-old Krystal Mitchel.
The cashier said that she could not serve him, as his daughter did not have any identification.
Sgt Cotton, of Upavon Way, Carterton, who was not in uniform when he made the purchase, said: “I was shocked, I have never complained about anything in my life before. I am not a person who gripes.
“I have come back from six months in Afghanistan, and to deal with that sort of jobsworth.
“It was common sense, as it was pretty obvious it was for me.
“Does this mean that anyone else buying alcohol with their children are not allowed to?”
The father-of-four, who will returned to the army this week, added: “I was in a good chirpy mood, and it really ruined my evening. I really thought it was a wind up and that somebody would jump out, like a Jeremy Beadle moment.”
The incident happened on Wednesday afternoon, as Sgt Cotton went to buy milk and bread with Krystal.
The 40-year-old said: “I then went to the self-service counter and proceeded to put my goods through the scanner. My daughter picked up the first two items and scanned them herself, a carton of milk and a packet of sweets, and then I took over. As I did so, the cashier called to me that she wanted to see ID for my daughter. I laughed at her thinking she was messing around, so I continued to scan the goods.
“Just as I was about to pay, the woman asked to see age verification for my daughter again, and I still thought she was winding me up. It soon became apparent she was serious.”
Lorna Bishop, spokesman for Midcounties Co-operative, said: “As a responsible community retailer, we have strict procedures on alcohol sales. If we suspect a customer is under 25 years old, we will ask for proof of age identification, and if we have suspicion that the purchase is being made for someone else, we are legally bound to refuse the sale. We apologise if this has caused any embarrassment, but we are legally required to refuse such a sale.”
Sgt Cotton added: “I understand that there is a problem with people buying alcohol by proxy, but I don’t exactly look like a chav, and I am a serving senior NCO.
“After recently returning from Afghanistan, I can’t believe the jobsworthiness of this woman, as it was plain to see I was doing a normal shopping like all the other thousands of people every day do with their children present.
“I even offered to take her home and come back later on my own, but they said I couldn’t do that either.”
Comments(27)
Marina Morris
says...
4:36pm Tue 16 Mar 10
Chilaili
says...
6:44pm Tue 16 Mar 10
Marina Morris
says...
8:19pm Tue 16 Mar 10
EB
says...
9:12pm Tue 16 Mar 10
scoobybzn
says...
8:26am Wed 17 Mar 10
armyphotographer
says...
9:26am Wed 17 Mar 10
AngelB
says...
9:29am Wed 17 Mar 10
PDplum
says...
9:43am Wed 17 Mar 10
Saskiacole
says...
10:37am Wed 17 Mar 10
PDplum wrote:So how does that work then ? Are you saying you would refuse to serve any customer who was accompanied by a minor i.e a mum of four buying her weekly shop and happens to purchase a bottle of wine to enjoy with her husband while eating a Sunday Roast ? Ridiculous !!!!!!! Maybe thats why your a former checkout worker as you didn't serve enough customers LOL
According to Licensing laws that was the correct course of action. Jusyt because he is a soldier its apparently a news story.
The fines for selling to underage are not worth the risk and as a former checkout worker i would have done the same.
scoobybzn
says...
11:49am Wed 17 Mar 10
sexybabe33
says...
11:59am Wed 17 Mar 10
AngelB
says...
12:59pm Wed 17 Mar 10
sexybabe33 wrote:The law is more crazy than I thought then, if all Minors have to produce ID in order for their parents to be able to buy alcohol (or presumably cigarettes; knives; certain glues etc etc). I'm suprised that most parents aren't teetotal! At what age is ID available? I don't think there was any indication in the article that the Minor was either purchasing, scanning or paying for the alcohol so I would stand by my view that the CoOp staff were just being over zealous!
I'm sure if it was the other way around and the cashier hadn't of asked for identification for this underage girl then he would still of gotten his 15minutes of fame and a big pay-out to go with it! Co-Op were following procedures. Every shop should already be doing this and if their not and they caught out then it'll be one henfty fine!
sexybabe33
says...
1:16pm Wed 17 Mar 10
AngelB wrote:In the eyes of the law they were following procedures legally. Anywhere you go, any shop in any town must do the same thing & follow this procedure. And most places also state on posters that the must check identification for anyone who looks under the age of 25. Like i said, If they hadn't of asked for identification no doubt this man would be making a small fortune. Obviously shops/cashiers are not going to check every single adult with a child but as it says in the article, it is procedure to check anyone's identification if they look under the age of 25 OR if there is any suspicion that the purchase is for someone else. On this occasion the alcohol wasn't for the minor but obviously it does happen quite alot otherwise there would not be such procedures in place. IT IS ILLEGAL TO SELL ALCOHOL TO ANYONE UNDER THE AGE OF 18. Shops must carry out the neccessary instructions to abide by this law. Under-age drinking is a big, serious & life threatening problem.
sexybabe33 wrote: I'm sure if it was the other way around and the cashier hadn't of asked for identification for this underage girl then he would still of gotten his 15minutes of fame and a big pay-out to go with it! Co-Op were following procedures. Every shop should already be doing this and if their not and they caught out then it'll be one henfty fine!The law is more crazy than I thought then, if all Minors have to produce ID in order for their parents to be able to buy alcohol (or presumably cigarettes; knives; certain glues etc etc). I'm suprised that most parents aren't teetotal! At what age is ID available? I don't think there was any indication in the article that the Minor was either purchasing, scanning or paying for the alcohol so I would stand by my view that the CoOp staff were just being over zealous!
AngelB
says...
1:30pm Wed 17 Mar 10
sexybabe33
says...
1:44pm Wed 17 Mar 10
AngelB
says...
2:48pm Wed 17 Mar 10
Niko Bellic
says...
4:03pm Wed 17 Mar 10
Niko Bellic
says...
4:09pm Wed 17 Mar 10
Power
says...
4:18pm Wed 17 Mar 10
AngelB
says...
6:32pm Wed 17 Mar 10
Niko Bellic wrote:Thanks for the info Niko.
oh, and AngelB, you cant hire a van until you are 26 if that counts? Err... and wasn't Chicago Rock once 25 and older only? If only there were still 25+ clubs still around. I cant stand being given the stink eye from a boozed up 18 year old chav.
Saskiacole
says...
7:36pm Wed 17 Mar 10
scoobybzn wrote:I think its called artistic licence ie he probably wore the uniform at the request of the paper to illustrate a point to catch peoples attention as it obviously has or non of us would be talking about it.
okay i think everybody is missing the point here. The guy desreves total respect for the job he does and his integrity is not in question. I have donated to Help For Heroes and Afghan Heroes charities. The point is he didn't need to exploit the fact that he is in the armed forces to create sensationalist headlines. If it had happened to "average joe" it wouldn't have even made the paper. Yes the law is a pathetic one and common sense should have prevailed but does it warrant a photo shoot outside the co-op in uniform?...No
eczema10
says...
10:47pm Fri 19 Mar 10
arnoldsdog
says...
11:00am Sun 21 Mar 10
meme0205
says...
9:01pm Sun 21 Mar 10
thepinkshrimp
says...
1:54pm Mon 22 Mar 10
yentiw
says...
6:30pm Tue 23 Mar 10
Enter your postcode, town or place name
Find your next job now in Oxfordshire
Search Now »
Make a date in Oxfordshire now!
Search Now »
Oxfordshire homes for sale and to let
Search Now »
Cars for sale in Oxfordshire
Search Now »
PDplum says...
4:25pm Tue 16 Mar 10
The fines for selling to underage are not worth the risk and as a former checkout worker i would have done the same.