News RSS Feed


Hospital parking fees cause anger


HOSPITAL patients and visitors in Oxfordshire have backed a consumer group’s claim that parking charges are too high and there is a shortage of spaces.

Which? said people using hospitals across the UK faced difficulties finding car parking spaces and dealing with payment systems and charges.

A survey of 1,001 people found 67 per cent who had used an NHS hospital car park in the past two years thought the charges were too high, and more than half had problems finding a space.

Almost half felt the whole experience added to the stress of their visit.

Last night, patient representatives backed the survey’s findings, reporting similar problems at Oxfordshire’s hospitals.

The Oxford Radcliffe Hospitals NHS Trust, which runs the John Radcliffe Hospital and Churchill Hospital in Oxford and The Horton Hospital in Banbury, generated £2.2m in revenue from parking charges in 2007-8.

However, the trust said its fees were fair and effective.

It said charges were necessary to stop drivers abusing the car park and to ensure the running costs did not come out of patient funds.

At the Oxford hospitals, visitors pay £2.50 to park for up to three hours. The Horton charges £2 for the first three hours and £3 for six hours.

The trust said its car parks were not run for profit and fees were last increased in 2005, when they rose by 10 per cent. In 2007-08, the fees generated a £300,000 surplus, which was ploughed back into patient care.

Janet Dineen, 52, of Sinodun Road, Didcot, visited the JR several times a year with her late daughter Sarah Swanborough. She said: “They’re robbing the elderly, the sick and disabled and it’s disgusting. It adds to the stress of going to hospital.”

Jacquie Pearce-Gervis, of Patient Voice in Oxford, said: “What I think is worrying is that the cost seems to be creeping up without the public noticing.

“They started off quite fair but they’re creeping up and a trip to hospital can be very expensive when you take into account the cost of petrol.”

Chris Ringwood, of Patient Voice in Banbury, said: “ The big problem is that those people who are having to visit the hospital on a regular basis resent the parking charges.”

An ORH spokesman said the variation in charges was because there was less public transport at the Horton.

She said the trust was cited as an example of good practice by Macmillan Cancer Care for the parking arrangements for cancer patients, adding: “We offer a range of free or discounted parking to a wide range of patient and visitor groups.”

She added: “We feel that our car parking systems operate in the most effective and fair way possible, within the constraints set, and our patient feedback supports this. However, we’re not complacent and are always looking at how to improve further.”

eallen@oxfordmail.co.uk

Comments(13)

janny1960 says...
7:10pm Thu 11 Mar 10

car park 1 at the JR is a disgrace, it's full of pot holes and presently smaller than it should be due to work going on around it. Car parking fees in the hospital are extortionate especially presently when the state of them is a disgrace!!!!

Berty says...
7:13pm Thu 11 Mar 10

It makes me so angry that when I take my sick son to hospital I have to pay to park, even though I can't park anywhere near A&E, and have to run down the hill to get a crappy wheelchair so I can bring him in. I should perhaps call an ambulance, as later in the week I then have to take my sick son with me after he's discharged, still fighting for breath when he wlaks, and pay a fortune at the parking office to get my car out of the car park.
It is a charge on being sick; pure and simple.

Lord Palmerston says...
7:46pm Thu 11 Mar 10

It is a charge on being sick; pure and simple.
It is indeed, but don't expect it to get better. Hospital Consultants have gold plated pensions north of 60k a year. Someone's got to pay.

JanetJ says...
7:48pm Thu 11 Mar 10

When my son was in hospital for 2 weeks I visited twice a day and other family members visited when they could. It was always a problem finding a space and was quite an extra expense by the end.

Oxford resident says...
8:48pm Thu 11 Mar 10

The Trust which runs our hospitals should be ashamed of charging people so much, especially at a time when visitors are very vulnerable: worried about their sick relatives or friends, and often having to pay repeated visits and travel long distances.

Mr Ben says...
8:49am Fri 12 Mar 10

Hum... It's really strange: I don't have a problem with the parking cost at all - I do think it's pretty reasonable, too (I am regular user of the car parks and on a low income).

I do sometimes take the bus out of concern for not being able to find a parking space though - but that's not a criticism as nowhere can have infinite amount of parking. If there was too much parking, people who could take the bus, would end up taking the car.

And *everywhere* has pot holes at the moment - because of the prior freezing conditions. They're doing their best... And considering we're getting our treatments on the NHS for free (or a much *much* reduced fee) I'm not sure I have much to grumble about with the parking cost. :)

Nick Mawer says...
9:10am Fri 12 Mar 10

Parking is a problem at ALL Oxford Hospitals. I have every sympathy for patients, but the problems facing staff every single day are serious as well. I wonder why? Does it have anything to do with the anti car brigade at Oxford City Council?

Andrew:Oxford says...
11:06am Fri 12 Mar 10

It's exactly to do with the anti-car brigade at OCC. There is so little parking around Oxford that if the hospital charges were to drop, they'd be swamped with non-hospital related parking. Sometimes I wonder if the land South of Grenoble Road should be used to build a brand new "Radcliffe Infirmary" simply to reduce the pressure on Headington as a consequence of having both the JR & the Churchill. That way it would also be in South Oxfordshire and outside the manipulation of Oxford City Council.

firstwitney says...
11:12am Fri 12 Mar 10

I visited the auidology dept this week .I was there about an hour and it cost me £1 to park which I think is very reasonable.
What people must realise is that everything comes at a price and if there was no charge for parking then the money would have to be paid from another budget.

Sid Hunt says...
11:36am Fri 12 Mar 10

I agree with Andrew re the state of parking and the influx of non-hospital related parking if charges are reduced. I think the authorities missed a golden opportunity by not building a new hospital on the site of the old car works at Cowley. The existing infrastructure would support the traffic flows and would have allowed for multi storey car parks plus dedicated ingress / egress for emergency vehicles to be constructed.

Adrian1 says...
4:30pm Fri 12 Mar 10

Had reason to attend the hospitals a lot recently. I'm assuming that the parking charges subsidise the hospital budget in some way? I would be annoyed to find that all profit simply goes to a private firm and its shareholders. I feel sorry for the staff who have to put up with the charges every day and the inflated shop charges too.

Berty says...
9:56pm Fri 12 Mar 10

Interesting to read these replies. At a time when you have loved ones seriously ill, the last thing you think about is parking money. I couldn't work, and still have no secure employment, because of my son's illness. If I leave him in hospital alone he isn't geven nebulisers on time, and doesn't get meals given to him. The NHS is asking us to give them help on the wards for free, which they COULD NOT function safely without, and then pay parking for the privilege. That low-paid staff also have to pay is nothing short of scandalous. It never used to be this way, and it shouldn't be this way when NHS managers are being given hotel rooms for conferences and buffets for training days that would do justice to a corporate board room.

LadyPenelope says...
11:03am Tue 16 Mar 10

I didn't find the charges too bad in the hospital car park for a 1-off trip, but I was almost late for my appointment due to the amount of time it took me to find a space (people are supposed to park BETWEEN the white lines, not over them - stupid 4x4s!).
I'm surprised Oxford hasn't taken note from Germany or France, where they have underground parking everywhere, rather than over-ground multistory. That way you can have your building on top, with sufficient parking underneath.


Most popular


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »

Local Businesses