When It Happens Panel Get involved: send your photos, videos, news & views by texting 'OXFORD NEWS' to 80360 or email
6:30am Monday 1st March 2010
A MOTHER has been warned she will face legal action if her Internet campaign against a school headteacher escalates into defamation.
Samantha Barson criticised the performance of Rose Hill Primary School headteacher Sue Mortimer on the social networking site Facebook after she claims five complaints to the school failed to address the bullying of her son.
The school’s governors wrote to her to warn her she could face “court proceedings” if she made defamatory comments about Mrs Mortimer.
They also wrote to facebook.com to request her webpage was removed, but Facebook said Mrs Barson had “every right” to post the comments.
Last night the mum of five, from St Martin’s Road, claimed she was forced to use Facebook because she felt her initial complaints to the school were not taken seriously.
At least 10 other parents have commented on the Facebook page, saying their children have also been bullied at the school.
Mrs Barson said: “How dare the governors threaten me with legal action for speaking my mind. What happened to free speech in this country?
“Bullying is a huge problem at the school and nobody is doing anything to stop it.
“Mrs Mortimer is just burying her head in the sand and this disgraceful letter is the final straw.”
Despite repeated requests from the Oxford Mail, both Mrs Mortimer and Oxfordshire County Council have refused to comment.
Mrs Mortimer said previously that she had reviewed the school’s anti-bullying policy, and added: “Each incident is carefully investigated and documented and appropriate sanctions are then implemented. Should any parent have any concern, they should speak to either myself or the school’s special needs coordinator.”
The letter sent to Mrs Barson was signed by chairman of governors Ali Akkas and vice chairman Robin Gill.
Mrs Barson, who has five children at the school, claims she contacted the school five times to complain after her seven-year-old son complained he had been punched and kicked.
She said: “When I approached Mrs Mortimer it was almost impossible to get a meeting. I eventually got a chat, but nothing happened.”
Jemma Crowder, who has two children at the school, said: “I really want to move my children.”
Grandmother-of-two Jackie Osmak said: “Something seems to be wrong every day.”
Facebook spokesman Sophy Silver said: “[Mrs Barson] has every right, within the abuse standards, to critique the performance of the headmaster at the school.”
dhearn@oxfordmail.co.uk
Richard MacKenzie, Witney says...
9:15am Mon 1 Mar 10
Cluck79, Oxford says...
9:22am Mon 1 Mar 10
tonybrett, Oxford says...
9:46am Mon 1 Mar 10
maxy2, aston says...
10:59am Mon 1 Mar 10
maxy2, aston says...
11:13am Mon 1 Mar 10
LittleBrother, Oxford says...
12:12pm Mon 1 Mar 10
commonutd, Oxford says...
3:25pm Mon 1 Mar 10
SAMANTHA BARSON, oxford says...
8:05pm Mon 1 Mar 10
SAMANTHA BARSON, oxford says...
8:42pm Mon 1 Mar 10
LittleBrother wrote:well little brother..... as ive already stated, if you wish to view my facebook page and all status's made by me, including the numerous parents comments. then please feel free to request me , i will accept you, then you can judge for yourself. i have nothing to hide and its not about me its about the children.........
"How dare the governors threaten me with legal action for speaking my mind. What happened to free speech in this country?" We do have free speech, but that goes hand in hand with the opportunity to libel and defame if what you say is not true.
AbZ__, Oxford says...
9:23pm Mon 1 Mar 10
AbZ__, Oxford says...
9:25pm Mon 1 Mar 10
Richard MacKenzie wrote:Agree
Can the OM not post the Facebook link here so that your readers can view the page and judge for themselves?
shipscat, Abingdon says...
9:31pm Mon 1 Mar 10
ta363, oxford says...
10:42pm Mon 1 Mar 10
oxford27, oxford says...
11:03pm Mon 1 Mar 10
SAMANTHA BARSON, oxford says...
11:06pm Mon 1 Mar 10
ta363 wrote:i do respect what you have to say, but this isnt about facebook, this is just distracting from the issue at hand of the numerous bullys in the said school .yes i did make several complaints and attempts to see the headmistress. talking of which, are you and i talking about the same school???? if so are you on the board of governers????? facebook was my last resort. if you had seen my page then youd know, that i actually put out a plea to ask other parents if they had children whom were or had been bullied at said school.
I understand the difficulty when a child is being bullied and the parent's difficulty in sorting the problem. However comments made on Facebook are hardly likely to solve anything, they may grab attention and allow us to 'slag' people off: but in the long run these derogatory remarks will really get us nowhere. I do understand the difficulty that Mrs Barson is suffering as the head teacher has been unable to meet with her. However if Mrs Barson was to constantly challenge her - through phone calls, letters, demanding to see the headteacher, in my opinion, is better than simply making comments on Facebook. My experience of the school and the head teacher is that it is friendly and approachable. I feel disheartened to hear that a child is being bullied but I feel that facebook is not the right way to tackle this problem. Agree with LittleBrother: the comments need to be actually true before you can defame someone. Secondly, a letter from the board of govenors shows that the school is a tight knit community... they work together to make things better... Has Mrs Barson actually written to the board of governors? I would like to know that before I make any further comments about it.
SAMANTHA BARSON, oxford says...
11:09pm Mon 1 Mar 10
oxford27 wrote:the reason why this "group" is unaccessable is because its not a GROUP!!! it was my PERSONAL page.
Matters involving bullying should be dealt with internally in any institution. Expressing such intimate problems to the press only inflates problems. Also why is there a repetition of people being unable to access this facebook group?
ta363, oxford says...
12:03am Tue 2 Mar 10
SAMANTHA BARSON wrote:Did you try to make an attempt to contact the board of governors though? That is my question... We are talking about the same school (Rose Hill Primary School Oxford) and no, I am not on the board either. I just think, maybe, before going to facebook as a last resort there could have been other ways to address the situation- by trying to contact the governors. Although I understand your frustrations and your view that facebook was the only way to attract attention, I just feel that the governors could have been contacted? I know the board personally and feel that they are supportive and would have tried to help, but it's easy to say what should have been done in hind sight!
ta363 wrote:i do respect what you have to say, but this isnt about facebook, this is just distracting from the issue at hand of the numerous bullys in the said school .yes i did make several complaints and attempts to see the headmistress. talking of which, are you and i talking about the same school???? if so are you on the board of governers????? facebook was my last resort. if you had seen my page then youd know, that i actually put out a plea to ask other parents if they had children whom were or had been bullied at said school.
I understand the difficulty when a child is being bullied and the parent's difficulty in sorting the problem. However comments made on Facebook are hardly likely to solve anything, they may grab attention and allow us to 'slag' people off: but in the long run these derogatory remarks will really get us nowhere. I do understand the difficulty that Mrs Barson is suffering as the head teacher has been unable to meet with her. However if Mrs Barson was to constantly challenge her - through phone calls, letters, demanding to see the headteacher, in my opinion, is better than simply making comments on Facebook. My experience of the school and the head teacher is that it is friendly and approachable. I feel disheartened to hear that a child is being bullied but I feel that facebook is not the right way to tackle this problem. Agree with LittleBrother: the comments need to be actually true before you can defame someone. Secondly, a letter from the board of govenors shows that the school is a tight knit community... they work together to make things better... Has Mrs Barson actually written to the board of governors? I would like to know that before I make any further comments about it.
Pierre My, East Of Green Road says...
12:07am Tue 2 Mar 10
SAMANTHA BARSON, oxford says...
9:32am Tue 2 Mar 10
ta363 wrote:no i didnt contact the board if govoners . its not them thats responsable for my sons safety and care whilst in rosehill primary from 9am -3pm. that is the role of the headmistress is it not? also when your sent people you dont even know to "deal" with the issue , that made me more irate. id asked to see mrs mortimer from the start and had asked specifically for her, not the school manager , nor the senco , nor another person whose title im un-sure of. surely this is down to the headmistress. also may i say that whilst my son was enduring the abuse at the hands of a bully , for a week. in the same said week, the school was promoting a anti-bullying campaign. if that is not hypocracy what is??? you then wonder why im not happy with the outcome of the meeting????? bully kept in at all breaks(old detention), and helped to make better choices???? what who is gna be their next victim??? or what theyre gna do next????
SAMANTHA BARSON wrote:Did you try to make an attempt to contact the board of governors though? That is my question... We are talking about the same school (Rose Hill Primary School Oxford) and no, I am not on the board either. I just think, maybe, before going to facebook as a last resort there could have been other ways to address the situation- by trying to contact the governors. Although I understand your frustrations and your view that facebook was the only way to attract attention, I just feel that the governors could have been contacted? I know the board personally and feel that they are supportive and would have tried to help, but it's easy to say what should have been done in hind sight!ta363 wrote: I understand the difficulty when a child is being bullied and the parent's difficulty in sorting the problem. However comments made on Facebook are hardly likely to solve anything, they may grab attention and allow us to 'slag' people off: but in the long run these derogatory remarks will really get us nowhere. I do understand the difficulty that Mrs Barson is suffering as the head teacher has been unable to meet with her. However if Mrs Barson was to constantly challenge her - through phone calls, letters, demanding to see the headteacher, in my opinion, is better than simply making comments on Facebook. My experience of the school and the head teacher is that it is friendly and approachable. I feel disheartened to hear that a child is being bullied but I feel that facebook is not the right way to tackle this problem. Agree with LittleBrother: the comments need to be actually true before you can defame someone. Secondly, a letter from the board of govenors shows that the school is a tight knit community... they work together to make things better... Has Mrs Barson actually written to the board of governors? I would like to know that before I make any further comments about it.i do respect what you have to say, but this isnt about facebook, this is just distracting from the issue at hand of the numerous bullys in the said school .yes i did make several complaints and attempts to see the headmistress. talking of which, are you and i talking about the same school???? if so are you on the board of governers????? facebook was my last resort. if you had seen my page then youd know, that i actually put out a plea to ask other parents if they had children whom were or had been bullied at said school.
SAMANTHA BARSON, oxford says...
11:17am Tue 2 Mar 10
Pierre My wrote:thankyou pierre!!!! if only i had time to tell you the full story, of how people were "persuaded" to come and talk to me and find out what i was up to....... oh yes this situation was not followed totally by proceedure. i put my hands up fully that i didnt follow it to the rule but as a parent youll do what has to be done for your children, thats what parents do.
Says all about the arrogance of The headmistress and governers, they think they can bully and frighten 1 lady with a letter. But when the big boys get involved they sh!t themselves and run away, hence no comment. You should be ashamed and resign immediately.
yummymummy10, oxford says...
5:46pm Tue 2 Mar 10
SAMANTHA BARSON, oxford says...
10:19pm Tue 2 Mar 10
Budowaah, Bicester says...
4:05pm Wed 3 Mar 10
yummymummy10, oxford says...
4:27pm Fri 5 Mar 10
Enter your postcode, town or place name
Find your next job now in Oxfordshire
Search Now »
Make a date in Oxfordshire now!
Search Now »
Oxfordshire homes for sale and to let
Search Now »
Cars for sale in Oxfordshire
Search Now »
Jamie Burns, Oxford says...
6:46am Mon 1 Mar 10
We went through exactly the same thing with Oxford School. It is no longer about the children and the bullying they have to endure, it is purely about protecting the teachers.
Even the County Council refused to acknowledge a problem and yet six months later removed the whole Governing body because of their failings in dealing with issues.
Schools in Oxfordshire have an epidemic of bullying and yet NOBODY with any real authority is prepared to stand up, be counted and deal with it.