Bid to build swimming pool in basement alarms author neighbour

thisisoxfordshire: Mark Haddon Mark Haddon

IT’S the curious incident of the pool in the basement.

Oxford Preservation Trust, Oxford Civic Society and well-known author Mark Haddon have all weighed into a row over plans to create a large basement with a swimming pool under a house in North Oxford.

Craig Burkinshaw has applied to Oxford City Council for planning permission to build a side extension onto the house on the corner of Farndon Road and Warnborough Road and dig out a basement underneath it which would be used for a swimming pool, gym, sauna room and two guest bedroom suites.

Mr Haddon, who wrote popular novel The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, and lives next door to Mr Burkinshaw, has written to the city council objecting to the plans.

In his letter he said: “We have no aesthetic objections to the plans, but the works would cause us a great deal of disturbance and inconvenience over a long period.

“More importantly the project would involve excavation onto our property, the temporary loss of walls, flowerbeds and our shed/bike store, and the permanent loss of two mature trees.”

His wife has also objected on the basis that the building work would take a long time and cause a “great deal of noise and disturbance”.

Related links

In his application Mr Burkinshaw says he has owned the property in Farndon Road for “a number of years” but bought the adjoining house in Warnborough Road last year.

He has since been given planning permission by the city council to turn them into one home.

Debbie Dance, the director of Oxford Preservation Trust, says the current plans go too far.

She said: “The proposal is to make two houses into one house and to add a large extension on the side, together with a large underground basement, so that the overall size of the house is very substantially larger than any one house in the area.

“What is presented is on a scale not previously envisaged in the North Oxford conservation area around Farndon and Warnborough Roads, and suggests a misunderstanding of what constitutes the character of the neighbourhood, in its disregard for the size and settings of the other houses in the area.”

Peter Thompson, chairman of Oxford Civic Society, said giving planning permission to this scheme would set a precedent for similar proposals.

He said: “These operations, together with the very substantial excavation and materials disposal activities, will generate a large number of traffic movements, of heavy goods vehicles, causing considerable and prolonged severe nuisance to neighbours, potential damage to the residential streets and contributing to congestion on Woodstock Road and air pollution in the neighbourhood.”

Last year Kensington and Chelsea Borough Council introduced a ban on so-called “iceberg homes” with mega-basements after a surge in applications from wealthy owners seeking to bypass planning restrictions by extending homes downwards.

In his application Mr Burkinshaw, who was unavailable for comment, said “very little” of the basement will be visible from ground level.

No date has yet been set for the plan to come before city councillors.

Comments (9)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

9:09am Fri 14 Feb 14

Andrew:Oxford says...

What the quotes really come down to is:-

"It's not fair! They shouldn't be allowed a bigger house than me."

Outwith flood areas and high groundwater areas of Oxford, all new homes should be built with a basement as a matter of course.
What the quotes really come down to is:- "It's not fair! They shouldn't be allowed a bigger house than me." Outwith flood areas and high groundwater areas of Oxford, all new homes should be built with a basement as a matter of course. Andrew:Oxford

9:34am Fri 14 Feb 14

shippondame says...

Why would this gentleman need a swimming pool when he can swim in the streets of Oxford?
Why would this gentleman need a swimming pool when he can swim in the streets of Oxford? shippondame

12:03pm Fri 14 Feb 14

locodogz says...

shippondame wrote:
Why would this gentleman need a swimming pool when he can swim in the streets of Oxford?
His will be a private swimming pool
[quote][p][bold]shippondame[/bold] wrote: Why would this gentleman need a swimming pool when he can swim in the streets of Oxford?[/p][/quote]His will be a private swimming pool locodogz

11:39pm Fri 14 Feb 14

sarahmw says...

Why has no one mentioned how excavating such a huge area underground and replacing this permeable surface with impermeable materials will affect the water table?

One of the problems is that water - and sewage - has no where to go and is coming up manholes, instead of going 'down' them.

Why add to the problem?
Why has no one mentioned how excavating such a huge area underground and replacing this permeable surface with impermeable materials will affect the water table? One of the problems is that water - and sewage - has no where to go and is coming up manholes, instead of going 'down' them. Why add to the problem? sarahmw

8:32am Sat 15 Feb 14

Sophia says...

If we had fair taxes rich parasites wouldnt be abe to make their neighbours lives miserable with egomaniac projects like this. Disgusting self indulgence when so many lack any sort of home
If we had fair taxes rich parasites wouldnt be abe to make their neighbours lives miserable with egomaniac projects like this. Disgusting self indulgence when so many lack any sort of home Sophia

8:33am Sat 15 Feb 14

Sophia says...

Andrew:Oxford wrote:
What the quotes really come down to is:-

"It's not fair! They shouldn't be allowed a bigger house than me."

Outwith flood areas and high groundwater areas of Oxford, all new homes should be built with a basement as a matter of course.
No what it comes down to is a rich egomaniac wanting to make his neighbours lives miserable for some vanity project
[quote][p][bold]Andrew:Oxford[/bold] wrote: What the quotes really come down to is:- "It's not fair! They shouldn't be allowed a bigger house than me." Outwith flood areas and high groundwater areas of Oxford, all new homes should be built with a basement as a matter of course.[/p][/quote]No what it comes down to is a rich egomaniac wanting to make his neighbours lives miserable for some vanity project Sophia

2:13pm Sat 15 Feb 14

Andrew:Oxford says...

Sophia wrote:
Andrew:Oxford wrote:
What the quotes really come down to is:-

"It's not fair! They shouldn't be allowed a bigger house than me."

Outwith flood areas and high groundwater areas of Oxford, all new homes should be built with a basement as a matter of course.
No what it comes down to is a rich egomaniac wanting to make his neighbours lives miserable for some vanity project
I guess you are troubled by people with money employing local civil engineers, groundworkers, builders, electricians, plumbers, joiners, tilers, architects, drivers, technicians and so forth on a major private project.
[quote][p][bold]Sophia[/bold] wrote: [quote][p][bold]Andrew:Oxford[/bold] wrote: What the quotes really come down to is:- "It's not fair! They shouldn't be allowed a bigger house than me." Outwith flood areas and high groundwater areas of Oxford, all new homes should be built with a basement as a matter of course.[/p][/quote]No what it comes down to is a rich egomaniac wanting to make his neighbours lives miserable for some vanity project[/p][/quote]I guess you are troubled by people with money employing local civil engineers, groundworkers, builders, electricians, plumbers, joiners, tilers, architects, drivers, technicians and so forth on a major private project. Andrew:Oxford

8:54pm Sat 15 Feb 14

EMBOX2 says...

I assume he has applied to Crown Estates, as everyone knows, you don't own more than 4ft under the lowest level of your property. Dig deeper and Her Maj needs to say yes.
I assume he has applied to Crown Estates, as everyone knows, you don't own more than 4ft under the lowest level of your property. Dig deeper and Her Maj needs to say yes. EMBOX2

10:36am Mon 3 Mar 14

Harold of Oxford says...

Haddon should make friends with Burkinshaw, rather than complaining. The plans sound awesome and, if he's nice, Burkinshaw might let Haddon take a swim from time to time. (In exchange for neighbourly home baked pies, poetry, short stories etc).
Haddon should make friends with Burkinshaw, rather than complaining. The plans sound awesome and, if he's nice, Burkinshaw might let Haddon take a swim from time to time. (In exchange for neighbourly home baked pies, poetry, short stories etc). Harold of Oxford

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree