City seeks to adopt planning system inspired by the Swiss

The Swiss system

Cllr James Fry

First published in News thisisoxfordshire: Photograph of the Author by , Council Reporter, also covering Oxford city centre. Call me on 01865 425429

OXFORDSHIRE’S rolling countryside might have nothing on Switzerland’s impressive mountain ranges, but that is not stopping Oxford City Council from taking inspiration from the Alps.

The city council is piloting a Swiss planning system which involves planning applicants indicating the outlines of a proposed new development by using thin poles topped with horizontal markers.

A number of applicants are already in discussions with the council over using the system but the authority will not reveal who and where they are. The idea has been proposed by city councillor James Fry, who represents North ward, as a result of the controversy surrounding Oxford University’s controversial flats in Roger Dudman Way, near Port Meadow.

He said: “I thought that there must be better ways to let people see the true scale of a proposed development on the site where it is actually proposed to site it, rather than having to rely upon architects’ diagrams placed on the city council website. When I asked people about alternative approaches outside Oxford, a good friend said that he had seen an excellent scheme in one of the Swiss cantons.

“To get this moving as soon as possible, I would like to appeal to residents who are thinking of submitting an application, such as for an extension for which they would like to avoid antagonising their neighbours, to get in touch with me and the planning department about volunteering to be part of the pilot scheme, and we will work together to take this forward.”

Related links

As part of the scheme used in Basel-Landschaft – called Bauprofil – all buildings of up to three storeys should be fully profiled using poles with horizontal markers.

Whether the roof is pitched or flat should also be indicated using slats.

City council spokeswoman Louisa Dean said: “Councillor Fry asked whether we could pilot the procedure – where planning applicants are obliged to indicate the outlines of a proposed new development by using thin poles, topped with horizontal markers.

“We have said we will see if any applicants would be willing to put up such poles.

“Whilst we are working to see if this can be arranged on a few sites at the moment, it is not possible to publish details of where and when this may happen.”

Comments (5)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

12:25pm Wed 8 Jan 14

King Joke says...

Maybe for the Northern Gateway development they should put thin poles with horizontal markers every 5 m along all the main roads for several miles around to simulate the traffic congestion it will cause.
Maybe for the Northern Gateway development they should put thin poles with horizontal markers every 5 m along all the main roads for several miles around to simulate the traffic congestion it will cause. King Joke
  • Score: 5

12:49pm Wed 8 Jan 14

Andrew:Oxford says...

Isn't there some form of "augmented reality" App that can do this? Having a reasonably good imagination might help too...

Either way, I don't support any Alpine visits to assess alternative systems.
Isn't there some form of "augmented reality" App that can do this? Having a reasonably good imagination might help too... Either way, I don't support any Alpine visits to assess alternative systems. Andrew:Oxford
  • Score: -26

2:00pm Wed 8 Jan 14

Dilligaf2010 says...

It's all very well positioning thin wooden poles, but that won't show the full impact, it would be better to encase the framework in plastic sheeting, that would give a more accurate indication.
It's all very well positioning thin wooden poles, but that won't show the full impact, it would be better to encase the framework in plastic sheeting, that would give a more accurate indication. Dilligaf2010
  • Score: -42

2:02pm Wed 8 Jan 14

King Joke says...

I can see the shortcomings of this system quickly being exposed and some bright spark suggesting that, er, developers produce computer models of the new developments and post them on the council website...
I can see the shortcomings of this system quickly being exposed and some bright spark suggesting that, er, developers produce computer models of the new developments and post them on the council website... King Joke
  • Score: 3

11:49pm Wed 8 Jan 14

Myron Blatz says...

Sorry, does this also mean that Oxford City Councillors will have to walk around when door-knocking prior to the forthcoming City Council elections in May, wearing two poles - one showing 'virtual promises' and the other showing what they will actually do, once elected?
Sorry, does this also mean that Oxford City Councillors will have to walk around when door-knocking prior to the forthcoming City Council elections in May, wearing two poles - one showing 'virtual promises' and the other showing what they will actually do, once elected? Myron Blatz
  • Score: -118

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree