£400m Westgate plans 'bad for heritage', says city trust

thisisoxfordshire: Preservation trust director Debbie Dance Preservation trust director Debbie Dance

OXFORD Preservation Trust has criticised the developers behind the Westgate scheme and is “extremely disappointed” by the proposals.

In a letter to Oxford City Council, trust director Debbie Dance said that key details are missing from the plans. She has urged the city council to veto the scheme as there is not “sufficient detail or certainty” and aspects are against policies on height and heritage.

The Westgate Alliance has submitted outline plans for the £400m redevelopment which will include a 10,000sq ft John Lewis store, as well as cafés, shops, restaurants and a cinema.

But the trust says this outline approach lacks key details.

Ms Dance writes: “We have met with the applicants in a spirit of co-operation, ready to engage and have an open dialogue.

“We are therefore extremely disappointed with the application that has come forward.

“The applicants have told us this outline approach is usual, even in an historic city of the importance of Oxford.

“They state they need this level of flexibility as they do not yet know who the tenants will be other than John Lewis.”

Ms Dance says there are no details on mass of the buildings, no dimensions and only indicative plans for where streets and public squares might go.

The plans were put in last September. A decision is expected early next year.

Construction could begin later in the year with the new centre opening in 2017 – creating thousands of jobs.

The developers have defended their approach.

Sara Fuge, of the Westgate Alliance, said: “Outline applications are preferred for major applications. “It allows the developer to find out at an early stage whether a proposal is in principle acceptable.

Related links

“This allows the city council to control the scheme and allows the design to respond to changes in requirements from retailers.

“Westgate Alliance is conscious of the historical importance of Oxford city.”

Oxford City Council refused to comment.

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

7:14am Mon 16 Dec 13

Andrew:Oxford says...

Oxford Preservation Trust are Critical?

Well, there's a surprise... I wasn't really expecting them to express delight...

As to the *mass* of the building. Surely that's not going to be known until the absolute minutiae of the specifications are calculated?

(The mass of a high quality engineering brick is around 3.3Kg)
Oxford Preservation Trust are Critical? Well, there's a surprise... I wasn't really expecting them to express delight... As to the *mass* of the building. Surely that's not going to be known until the absolute minutiae of the specifications are calculated? (The mass of a high quality engineering brick is around 3.3Kg) Andrew:Oxford

10:00am Mon 16 Dec 13

Gunslinger says...

Apart from its proximity to the castle, this is not exactly the prettiest corner of the city, so these concerns are a little far fetched. But beware groups like this - they managed to scupper the last redevelopment plans some 10 years ago.
Apart from its proximity to the castle, this is not exactly the prettiest corner of the city, so these concerns are a little far fetched. But beware groups like this - they managed to scupper the last redevelopment plans some 10 years ago. Gunslinger

6:45pm Mon 16 Dec 13

Citizen Sunday says...

Ms Dance writes: “We have met with the applicants in a spirit of co-operation..."

I very much doubt that, Debbie...
Any which way you cut it- irrespective of detailed designs and height limits-, the new Westgate development is quite clearly going to be large and modern. Everything the Preservation Trust abhors.
Ms Dance writes: “We have met with the applicants in a spirit of co-operation..." I very much doubt that, Debbie... Any which way you cut it- irrespective of detailed designs and height limits-, the new Westgate development is quite clearly going to be large and modern. Everything the Preservation Trust abhors. Citizen Sunday

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree